Leaf Spring Restoration Concours judging question

[Paulb]

When restoring original springs for concours after bead blasting do they need to redone in the manganese phosphate finish, or do they accept another coating without a point deduction?

[Bob Gaines]

When restoring original springs for concours after bead blasting do they need to redone in the manganese phosphate finish, or do they accept another coating without a point deduction?

There are any number of ways to get the end look. The point is to get the look as close to the original as possible. How well you are able to replicate the spring steel finish will determine if there are points deducted or not.For example some people use gunblue to duplicate the look however you can use that product and apply it wrong or have bad product and it will not look right.

[Paulb]

When restoring original springs for concours after bead blasting do they need to redone in the manganese phosphate finish, or do they accept another coating without a point deduction?

There are any number of ways to get the end look. The point is to get the look as close to the original as possible. How well you are able to replicate the spring steel finish will determine if there are points deducted or not.

If I am reading between the lines, don't take a chance and find someone that can do the manganese phosphate dipping. I still think I will be ready for Jacksonville. I'm getting excited. The only way to find out what I have overlooked. Ok, I lied, I am more nervous than I am excited 

[J_Speegle]

If I am reading between the lines, don't take a chance and find someone that can do the manganese phosphate dipping. I still think I will be ready for Jacksonville. I'm getting excited. The only way to find out what I have overlooked. Ok, I lied, I am more nervous than I am excited 

IMO take the comment as written. There are many paths to the goal. Investigate and choose the best for need. Originally they were not phosphated and the process if done incorrectly can mess up a set of springs through embrittlement. There are cold liquid products than can replicate the same heat treated oil quenched process used on them originally. Of course to the details correct you'll have to disassemble  since the clamps were not colored, heat treated or plated.

As in most related things and projects its a combination of a good product and the right technique. Since the springs are so long getting a consistent finish from one end to the other is one of the challenges