News:

We have implemented a Photo Gallery for hosting images right here on SAACFORUM. Check the How-To in News from HQ

Main Menu

Insurance

Started by shelbymann1970, May 27, 2025, 09:19:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

shelbymann1970

I know this has been discussed before but what are you guys using right now for insurance. American Modern raised my rates 25 percent as of a June renewal. Suggestions?
Shelby owner since 1984
SAAC member since 1990
1970 GT350 4 speed(owned since 1985).
  MCA gold 2003(not anymore)
1969 Mach1 428SCJ 4 speed R-code (owned since 2013)
"2nd" owner of 68 GT500 #1626

98SVT - was 06GT

I'm still using Haggerty - Our 1928 Model A added $14 to the policy (8 months remaining - 3 cars).
Previous owner 6S843 - GT350H & 68 GT500 Convert #135.
Mine: GT1 Mustang, 1998 SVT 32V, 1929 Model A Coupe, Wife's: 2004 Tbird
Member since 1975 - priceless

6T6SHELBY

I switched from Hagerty to Grundy two years ago. The premium was half of what Hagerty was with a high Agreed Value and a lower deductible.

Rickmustang

25 percent is pretty good these days, in my experience. Parish raised mine 80% and I switched to American Modern through a broker friend.

tesgt350

Have any of you ever had to file a Claim and if so, how were they to work with?  I recently had the chance to bring "LITTLE BIRD" back home.  A 1960 Thunderbird that I owned for about 8 Years working on it and sold it about 30 Years ago. It is about 3 feet shorter than Factory. I couldn't pass it up. 


TOBKOB


I'm still using Haggerty - Our 1928 Model A added $14 to the policy (8 months remaining - 3 cars).


Nice "A" ... :)
TOB
1969 GT350 owned since 1970

shelbymann1970

Quote from: Rickmustang on May 28, 2025, 05:47:49 AM25 percent is pretty good these days, in my experience. Parish raised mine 80% and I switched to American Modern through a broker friend.
to me a 25 percent raise is BS and too typical in the insurance industry. So the eycc c are telling me with zero claims the costs went up 25 percent in a year? American Modern also changed their policy for any new cars last year to min 2500 deductible which was ok for my GT500 since it is being restored and my mach1 and gt350 are grand fathered in at zero
Shelby owner since 1984
SAAC member since 1990
1970 GT350 4 speed(owned since 1985).
  MCA gold 2003(not anymore)
1969 Mach1 428SCJ 4 speed R-code (owned since 2013)
"2nd" owner of 68 GT500 #1626

pchmotoho

Quote from: tesgt350 on May 28, 2025, 07:41:27 AMHave any of you ever had to file a Claim and if so, how were they to work with?  I recently had the chance to bring "LITTLE BIRD" back home.  A 1960 Thunderbird that I owned for about 8 Years working on it and sold it about 30 Years ago. It is about 3 feet shorter than Factory. I couldn't pass it up. 

Had to file a claim with Hagerty once.  They were excellent. 


TOBKOB

Quote"I'm still using Haggerty - Our 1928 Model A added $14 to the policy (8 months remaining - 3 cars)


Nice "A" ... :)
TOB

1969 GT350 owned since 1970

Lfino

Haggerty. Same rate as last year.

Mustang_Charlie

American Modern.  Close to same rate as last year- hard to tell as I sold one.

JWH

I stayed with American Modern. Yes, the cost is much higher and crazy high compared to what it was 5-6 years ago. I would caution to check the coverage limits and uninsured motorist coverage when comparing. American Modern offered much better coverage than Hagerty was my finding for about the same cost.
Jeff

shelbymann1970

Seems my policy doesn't exist with American Modern/Heacock. Seems Heacock is transitioning our policies to another company called American Family. Ive been trying to get someone to pull up mu policy for the last 1.5 hours so be forewarned if you have American Modern you may not be able to pull up your account until the transition is done. The reason I see for my policy going up 25 percent were things added to my policy that I didn't approve. So now I wait for Heacock or American Modern to call me back..... What a way to run a business....
Shelby owner since 1984
SAAC member since 1990
1970 GT350 4 speed(owned since 1985).
  MCA gold 2003(not anymore)
1969 Mach1 428SCJ 4 speed R-code (owned since 2013)
"2nd" owner of 68 GT500 #1626

shelbymann1970

If you have Heacock or American Modern I'd rethink about having them. A day later and they still cannot find my policy even though I have a renewal one sitting right in front of me with the policy number on it. For the record when I put my Gt500 on it it was a 2500 collision deductible and all future cars with them have that. My Gt350 and Mach1 were grandfathered in. Time to go insurance hunting.
Shelby owner since 1984
SAAC member since 1990
1970 GT350 4 speed(owned since 1985).
  MCA gold 2003(not anymore)
1969 Mach1 428SCJ 4 speed R-code (owned since 2013)
"2nd" owner of 68 GT500 #1626

6s2055

I have used Grungy for over 20 years. Each year I would make comparisons and no one was even close. Had a couple of clams, one a total. Never an issue or rate increase!